« Weil de Weil (1971) | Main | Vintage Perfume Ad: REO, the "World's First Cologne Exclusively for Gay Men" (1978) »

February 11, 2011

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a010535dc5a78970b0147e27e01ff970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Huffers vs. Scrubbers: What's On Your List?:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

kjanicki

I love your definitions. Hmm, I go through phases where some are my favourites, and I don't try many scrubbers, but right now I'd say...

Huffers: Soir de Lune, L'Ombre dans l'Eau, Bandit, Le Temps d'un Fete, Ormonde Jayne Tiare

Scrubbers: Amouage Opus I

Meg (Olenska)

Fantastic! I second your motion to institute "huffers" as the term of choice :D My huffers: L'Air du Desert Marocain, Arabie, Sacrebleu, Nuits de Scherrer, Lalique Flora Bella, and Un Bois Vanille. My scrubbers: Angel, the new YSL Opium (did someone leave the gas on?), and Vera Wang Princess.

Perfumaniac

I've been wanting to try Tiare, Kjanicki. That reminds me, there's a great Mona di Orio I need to put on this list...

Perfumaniac

Hi Meg/Olenska , Ouch, re: "Did someone leave the gas on?" So funny...

Is Nuits de Scherrer the same as Nuits Indienne? Because I've been wanting to try that one for a while. I LOVE Scherrer I, and Scherrer II with that pineapple note isn't half bad...

flippy

i think the first step is admitting you have a problem, so i am here to say that i can't stop huffing le labo oud 27.

Perfumaniac

Wait, flippy. I'm to blame for that, right?

Meg (Olenska)

RE: Nuits de Scherrer-- yes, it was indeed named Nuits Indienne when first released - then rechristened a few years afterward.

Elisa

Rumba is the first one that came to mind for me for scrubbers! Can't stand it. I've also been known to scrub L'Heure Bleue though I keep trying and retrying it but it just smells gross on me.

Too many huffers to mention (why wear something you don't love enough to huff?) but one that really keeps me huffing for hours is Cuir de Lancome. I also love to huff Belle en Rykiel.

Perfumaniac

Now I gotta try Cuir de Lancome and Belle en Rykiel, Elisa. Thanks! (I didn't even know Sonia Rykiel had a scent.)

Anne

I try to forget the scrubbers in my life! One that springs to mind is Flower by Kenzo. Lovely opening, but it transforms into a sour and metallic thing that I cannot stand.

Actually, I especially love the second skin perfumes, not perfumes you want to huff because they feel just perfectly right in a simple, non-perfumey sort of way. L'Heure Bleue creates almost this sort of effect because if its lovely 'perfume veil', but I do huff it sometimes. Dior's Granville (one of its new La Collection fragrances) is a second skin perfume for me - a strange mix of austerity and comfort. It's not vintage of course, but like a lot of the exclusive fragrances that Dior and Chanel have put out recently, it is both retro and modern in style.

Perfumaniac

Oh, I am with you re: Kenzo, Anne. I had heard so much about it, and recently (I know it's been out for a while) sprayed it on and it made me queasy. I don't think I liked anything about it. Interesting point about not wanting to huff subtle perfumes...

Steve Johnson

ALL-TIME HUFFS (SO FAR):
- BYREDO'S OUD IMMORTELLE - This so far is the sexiest damn thing I've ever sampled - anything comes down the pike hotter than this and my head will explode.
- GUERLAIN'S L'INSTANT POUR HOMME - perfect sophistication, mystery and intrigue in a bottle. James Bond can't carry himself better.
- AMOUAGE JUBILATION XXV - If Jefferson Airplane's song, White Rabbit, hadn't already been recorded, the first time anyone sampled this fragrance, it would have right then.

SCRUBBERS:
- anything sold as fragrance by Bath and Body Works. You might as well just dump a gallon of fruit jelly and Jolly Rancher juice all over yourself and call it good. HIDEOUS (and damn tenacious!)
- anything Chanel currently makes for men outside of Bleu.
- the original Aramis. Why would any man in his right mind think a fragrance that smells exactly like a dog wrapped up in a rug that was under the feet of 20 cigar-chomping poker players be a symbol of great scent? GODAWFUL, CHEAP and GHASTLY. Just dump the contents of your car ashtray down your neck and call it good if you like this.

Perfumaniac

Hi Steve,

Thanks for the amazing list. Now I must run and resniff Byredo's Oud Immortelle! Ditto on the Bath and Body Works anything. I do part ways with you, however, at vintage Aramis, which is one of my Huffers. It is dirty — and it is spectacular! But I guess I wanna smell like "a dog wrapped up in a rug that was under the feet of 20
cigar-chomping poker players." I'm crazy that way. ;-)

Tarleisio

Huffers! What a great term! Ooooh, where to start...

Vintage Huffers: Magie Noir, Dioressence, Cabochard, Bandit, Jolie Madame, Jicky parfum, Rive Gauche
Contemporary Huffers: Ambre Sultan, Boxeuses, Ubar (so beautiful it made me cry, and write about it, too!), Incense Extrème

Vintage scrubbers: Giorgio! and Giorgio Red, Poison, Fracas
Contemporary scrubbers: Anything with oud except M7 (I'm trying to love oud! I'm trying, but I'm. Just. Not. Feeling. It. ) Angel. Fruitchoulis. Eau Mega and Flowerbomb. Every Miss Dior and flanker currently in existence. I'm turning green just thinking about them...

Perfumaniac

Mmmmm, Magie Noir and Jicky...Tarleisio. And I need to try Ubar. A perfume that you can huff and then cry about? Yes, please! Some perfumes on your scrubbers list I love, but to each her own. :-)

mals86

So funny Elisa (Hi, Elisa!) huffs Cuir de Lancome... I love that one, but it's one of those that, to me, smells very different two inches above my wrist than huffed directly from the wrist, and I prefer the waft to the huff.

Elisa

CdL and BeR can both be found very affordably on the internet. Cuir is more classic, BeR is a more subtle riff on the Angel school.

Hi Mals! I like that phrase too, "I prefer the waft to the huff."

Amy

Some examples of my Huffers: Chanel Bois Des Iles, No. 22; SL Un Bois Vanille, Chergui; Diorella; AG Heure Exquise; Diptyque Eau Duelle; Hermes Un Jardin Sur Le Nil; CDG Ouarazate (sp?)

Some Scrubbers: AG Songes; SL Un Bois Sepia, Gris Clair; Caron Tabac Blond (modern version; never tried vintage); Tom Ford White Patchouli; KM Loukhoum; Angel Pivoine (the original is tolerable - barely - but the Pivoine variation is VILE!); EL Azuree

Jonno

I commend you, my friend, for this most useful addition to the perfumisti lexicon!

A few of my huffers: Aramis, Black Afgano, Bois Marocain, Fille en Aiguilles, M7, Mitsouko, Muscs Kublai Khan, Oud Wood (Tom Ford), CDG Ourzazate, Sycomore, Vettiveru

And the requisite scrubbers: Lonestar Memories (instant headache), Terre d'Hermes (ditto), Beyond Paradise for Men, and almost everything I've smelled from Bond No. 9 withe the possible exception of Silver Factory, which bored me more than anything.

Perfumaniac

You, Jonno, are a Huffer extraordinaire with extraordinary tastes. Happy Valentines Day!

Emma

What a great post!

Huffers: Une Fleur de Cassie (Editions de Parfums; Bellodgia (Caron); Amaranthine (Penhaligon's); Que Sais-Je? (Patou); My Sin (Lanvin).

Scrubbers: Ivoire (Balmain); Tubereuse (Caron); Dulcis in Fundo (Profumum); Volupte (De La Renta).

Scrubber-turned-Huffer: Songes (Annick Goutal)

Perfumaniac

Hi Emma. I must get my hands on Amaranthine. I keep hearing good things about it! And I've wanted Bellodgia for ages. I'm surprised Ivoire is on your Scrubber list, but that's just because I love it. As for Songes, it's good to know that a Scrubber can turn into a Huffer! I feel that I could be suggestible that way with lots of scents, but not with intensely fruity ones. That's where I draw the line...

Emma

I know, I'm definitely in the minority with Ivoire, as most people love it. Perhaps it will go the way of Songes with me, and turn into one I can love?! Here's hoping.

Dorette

Huffers: L'Heure Bleu (Guerlain), Ecusson (Jean D'Albret), Caleche (Hermes), Ma Griffe, Dior Dior, Tweed, Arpege, Le Dix (Balanciaga, Parure (Guerlain), Heure Exquise (Annick Goutal)

Scrubbers: Opium, Charlie, Poison, Angel (smell a trend?)

Perfumaniac

Dorette: Is the trend that nobody likes Angel? (Pssst: I love it!) I agree with almost everything on your Huffer list, though, espeically Ma Griffe, Arpege, and Parure! Thanks for stopping by.

Aniela

It is the trend. Widespread. Even in my country - which is a little peripheral to trends (Poland). Angel has become "I gave it to my mother" scent. I, on the contrary, as being the latecomer to many manias (so interesting to observe the remnants) start to discover it. Angel is full of everything what for me equals to atmosphere of weeks before Christmas.

Dorette

I just think it's too candy sweet. I don't like perfumes that arrive before the wearer and hang around too long after the wearer is gone.

I beleive it's perfumes on most scrubber lists that have caused the backlash against scents in general. The Poisons and Opiums of the perfume world are making life difficult for those of us who love vintage. What is the world coming to when perfume has to be banned!

Perfumaniac

At the risk of sounding like a gun advocate ("Guns don't kill people, people kill people"), I will say that I don't blame the big perfumes like Poison and Angel. I blame people who have no common sense when it comes to applying perfume. Don't put too much on!

breathe31

Huffers for me are as follows: L'Heure Bleue, MUST de Cartier, Annick Goutal's eau de Camille, Nocturnes de Caron,Calyx, Womanswear (Alexander Julian), Hanae Mori, Un Ete en Provence (Escada), Noa (Cacharel), Nikki de Sainte Phalle, Chanel's Cristalle (old formulation) and No.22.
Not too many in the Scrubber category (for I rarely meet a perfume that is so bad that I want to scratch it off my skin) but here it goes: Poison and Giorgio (both of which I actually enjoyed when they first came out but the overkill turned them into scrubbers for me).

breathe31

I should have added for men: HUFFERS- Drakkar Noir (hands down this one will turn me into putty in the hands of any man who wears it!), Grey Flannel (loved it so much I would actually wear it myself!), Paul Sebastian and Carolina Herrera for men. SCRUBBERS: Giorgio for men and Chaps (I once stopped dating someone because he wore this one with reckless abandonment!).

julie

Huffers: Mollie Parnis, Jicky, Shalimar, L'Heure Bleue, Panthère in EDT only! - see below!, Antilope, Private Collection, Queen by Queen Latifah.

Scrubbers: Youth Dew which has always been an unreconstructed Bleeecch to my nose, and Panthère parfum and EDP. How this fragrance was pure delight as EDT and pushy and oversharp as parfum and EDP baffles me. And the EDT is impossible to find.

brigitte

I'm looking at this from the point of being a minimalist (ie: if you were stranded on an island what 5 fragrances MUST you have with you-hey! Now THAT would make a great blog,Barbara!). Vintage huffers: Nocturnes d'Caron, Cristalle, Calyx (no reformulations,please!). Modern huffers would be: Annick Goutal's Eau de Camille (a gorgeous green for me) and Heaven (both of which you will soon be getting as samples,among other things).

As far as huffers go, husband (as well as my co-worker with whom I share an office) would have a list a mile long of fragrances I have worn that he (and she!) would LOVE to Brillo pad scrub off of me but honestly, I can't think of any vintage or modern scent that I have worn in these past 40 years that has brought me to the level of nausea (which would be my only condition to truly be a scrubber) with the exception of an essential oil blend I made recently which contained myrrh saffron, Indian Sandalwood, frankincense and spikenard. It made me so sick to my stomach I literally washed my arms about 7 times. Funny thing is even after all that scrubbing a faint scent lingered, which I actually liked!

brigitte

OOPS! Just realized that in the beginning of my second paragraph I referred to my husband's/co-worker's distaste in my fragrances as "huffers" when in actuality they are "scrubbers" as far as my husband/co-worker are concerned. A Freudian slip on my part ,as I really haven't met a fragrance that I absolutely detest!

Perfumaniac

Brigitte--

That unholy mix of saffron, spikenard, et al sounds intense! Good for you for trying to make something! I've always wanted to try spikenard, for the name alone.

I'm rarely an OMG get this off me type, but I couldn't scrub Kenzo Flower off fast enough. It made me queasy. Strange, because I know it's a favorite of many. I don't get it...

Oh, and I can't wait for my little package! ;-)

brigitte

Spikenard is an extremely ancient oil- in fact I read somewhere it was the oil that Mary Magdalene rubbed on Jesus's feet. I actually added a bit of cocoa to this blend which makes it a bit more palatable- I am going to send you a sample of this as well- let me know if you have to scrub it off! I have been having a lot of fun experimenting with essential oils and vodka- I have them "marinating" in my basement LOL!!!

Perfumaniac

Can't wait, Brigitte!

anonymous

This is a great thread. Funny though, I love Kenzo Flower and Angel too. For me they are definitely huffers, and Vanilla Noir by BBW is one that I love, for that matter anything in their vanilla range is nice. Scrubbers for me would be anything really strong, unfortunately I have to go with Giorgio on this one too.

brigitte

In my attempt to try and wean my 12 and 14 year old daughters off of their favorite, expensive, mainstream perfumes (ie: Chloe, DK Be Delicious, Daisy, Pink Sugar, etc) I purchases numerous samples from some indie/niche companies in hopes that amongst these they would find their "signature scent". Much to my surprise, I found some drop dead gorgeous fragrances that are real huffers for me: 1000 Flowers' Reglisse Noire, Ineke's Field Notes from Paris and Sonoma Scent Studio's Champagne de Bois. All three of these lines carry perfumes that are redolent of vintage. Yet, how could they NOT be with such notes as ambergris, tobacco leaf, oakmoss, labdanum, vetiver, anise,etc. with names like Tabac Aurea, Amber Noire, Incense Pure,etc. The beauty is that these fragrances are readily accessible for a reasonable price without having to hunt down and/or pay exorbitant prices on e-bay! Barbara, it would be so great if you could write a review on "VINTAGE INSPIRED MODERN SCENTS". If you need any samples to get you started I would be more than happy to send to you those that I have in my possession from the aforementioned indie/niche perfumers!

Perfumaniac

Hi Brigitte,

Love your idea about a discussion of modern perfumes that are vintage-inspired. I've been working on a post on Satan's Angel, Opus Oils' perfume tribute to an iconic burlesque dancer that went by that name and that's vintage in style...

And good for you for trying to get your daughters to like the good stuff, although, is the niche stuff more expensive than mainstream? You're a dedicated perfumista if that's the case!

brigitte

Actually I am finding the indie companies I mentioned above less expensive than the mainstream. Reglisse Noire (1000 Flowers) I got on sale and because it is a splash I don't over spray (which makes my husband and perfume hating co-worker very happy!). Laurie Erickson (Sonoma Scent Studio) makes her fragrances in perfume concentrations and with less application needed for good sillage a small bottle can last forever! With the Ineke line you can purchase a sampler of seven 2.5 ml for $25.00 but if you purchase a full size bottle you get the $25.00 back as a discount! All in all it's much less expensive than a bottle of the new Chloe or Daisy and you are getting quality perfume made with unusual, unique, vintage notes. As much as I love my vintage what I have I don't wear often for fear of using it up and not being able to replace it so easily. And heaven forbid that my daughters fall in love with a vintage scent that costs $300.00 a bottle on e-bay! Given that we all use fragrance on a daily basis I needed to find perfumes that can easily be replenished when the bottles are empty!

Paket Shop Hermes

So cute! I already like you on FB and also get your posts on Google Reader. :)

Mi Jong

Huffers: Chypre 1942 by Nobile 1942; Labdanum 18 by Le Labo; Dulcis in Fundo by Profumum; Fashion by Leonard.

Scrubbers: Could not bear to waste anything, so I sniff before I try it on. Once I spray I'm committed for the day. Some perfumes, I cross the street when I see them coming.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Book

Order Here

Vintage Perfume Reviews